Accused of murder, Dan Watson takes a quick look backward after closing arguments on Nov. 6. The jury hearing his case came back split - 7 guilty, 5 not guilty - creating a mistrial and setting Watson up for a second trial as soon as June 2027.
By Tom Peterson and Aaron Girdham
The Dalles, Ore., Nov. 16, 2026 — A Wasco County jury failed to reach a unanimous verdict in the murder trial of Dan Watson, ending deliberations with a 7-5 split and prompting prosecutors to announce plans for a new trial as early as June.
Wasco County District Attorney Kara Davis said seven jurors favored finding Watson guilty and five favored acquittal. After deliberating Friday, Nov. 6, and returning Monday, Nov. 9, the jury told Circuit Court Judge John Wolf that afternoon it could not reach an agreement and was unwilling to continue deliberating.
"No one was budging," Davis said, describing the jurors' positions. “That’s my belief.”
Amanda Harman
Watson is charged with murdering 35-year-old Amanda Harman, who was found stabbed to death in her home outside The Dalles on March 18, 2023.
"We will schedule for a new trial this summer," Davis said. "The earliest would be June."
Davis said Watson would remain in custody at NORCOR in The Dalles until the next trial begins.
"I am really gutted," Davis said. "I really care about Amanda's friends and family."
The jury's inability to reach a verdict came after an emotionally charged closing argument from Davis, who urged jurors to find Watson guilty based on what she described as the totality of the circumstantial evidence.
Davis argued Watson was the only person with a motive to kill Harman. She said there was no burglary, no threats, nothing that proceeded the murder, except a drastic falling out with her childhood friend Watson at a party four years earlier, where he made threats of harm.
She focused heavily on DNA evidence, including samples collected from the seat of Harman's Kubota side-by-side and from beneath one of her fingernails.
She pointed to testimony from Henry Tran, who said Harman had received a dip manicure just hours before her death. Davis argued that the DNA beneath Harman's fingernail could only have been deposited through physical contact with Watson during the killing.
District Attorney Kara Davis makes her final argument to the jury in the murder trial of Dan Watson on Nov. 6.
"The fact is, she fought back and that's how his DNA was under her fingernails," Davis told the jury.
Davis also described the DNA recovered from the Kubota as an "exact match" to a cheek swab collected from Watson during the investigation.
The defense argued that the presence of Watson's DNA did not establish that he committed the murder.
During closing arguments, Davis displayed graphic photographs of Harman's battered face and body on a large screen in the courtroom. She pointed to multiple contusions, arguing the injuries showed Harman had been punched repeatedly and had fought back, rather than sustaining the injuries through a fall or exercise.
She then displayed photographs of Harman's stab wounds and described how she died from blood loss into her body cavity.
At one point, Davis pounded her fist 11 times on the desk beside her, methodically reenacting the number of blows she said had been inflicted during the killing.
The courtroom, which held about 70 observers, fell silent. Soft crying could be heard, and several people left afterward.
Davis ended her argument by asking jurors to return a guilty verdict.
"You have enough evidence to find him guilty beyond a reasonable doubt; please do it."
Judge Wolf released the jury to deliberate shortly after 12:30 p.m. Friday, Nov. 6, following instructions on the law. The jurors returned Monday morning, Nov. 9, but sent a note to the judge in the early afternoon indicating they remained deadlocked and would not continue deliberations.
The trial began Oct. 28, with prosecutors emphasizing Harman's final hours and the physical evidence connecting Watson to the crime.
Senior Deputy District Attorney Caleb Berthelsen told jurors that although the case was titled State v. Watson, the focus should be on Harman.
"This is the case of Amanda Harman," he said during opening statements.
Berthelsen described Harman's final day, including getting her nails done around 5 p.m., picking up chicken wings and garlic bread bites at Domino's and texting a friend at approximately 10:15 p.m.
The text conversation abruptly stopped, he said, and Harman never completed her message.
Harman was found in her bathroom with 11 stab wounds. Medical Examiner Christopher Van Tilburg testified that she had extensive bruising to her head and wounds to her abdomen, torso, shoulders and neck. One wound punctured her heart.
Defense attorney Eberlein told jurors the state's case depended heavily on DNA evidence, which he characterized as mishandled. He also challenged the investigation, pointing to two other men he said were near the property and whose behavior warranted further scrutiny.
Defense Attorney Seth White takes the jury through the evidence, arguing repeatedly that the evidence is not enough to convict Dan Watson of murder beyond a reasonable doubt.
Defense attorney Seth White also questioned the DNA evidence, repeatedly pointing out that nothing in the case established "how or when" Watson's DNA got there. He argued that the DNA could have been transferred years earlier or through Watson's ex-wife, who had worked out with Harman.
White also introduced two peer-reviewed studies involving cases in which DNA transfer contributed to the arrests of people accused of rape and murder who were later found innocent and acquitted.
The defense also raised questions about the timeline of Harman's death and Watson's whereabouts, arguing that Watson had an alibi.
Eberlein said security footage Watson provided to investigators several days after the murder could have supported that account. However, police did not preserve the video by downloading it, and the files were lost when the video service automatically erased the recordings.
Davis challenged that theory, questioning Watson's intent in sending investigators seven video clips that were scheduled to be erased in less than three days.
During closing arguments, White challenged Davis' description of Watson as left-handed and her assertion that Harman had been beaten by a left-handed person before she was stabbed.
White then showed jurors a screenshot of Watson signing a police statement with his right hand during an interview with investigators in 2023.
With the jury unable to reach a verdict, the case now moves toward a second trial, potentially more than three years after Harman was killed. Watson remains in custody as prosecutors prepare to bring the case before another jury.